NOTE: Free essay sample provided on this page should be used for references or sample purposes only. The sample essay is available to anyone, so any direct quoting without mentioning the source will be considered plagiarism by schools, colleges and universities that use plagiarism detection software. To get a completely brand-new, plagiarism-free essay, please use our essay writing service.
One click instant price quote
Suck Out Your Gut By Sandy Naiman Suck Out Your Gut By Sandy Naiman And Turning Boys Into Girls By Michelle Mirror mirror on the wall who is the fairest of all! Good old days when women were the ones standing in front of the mirror for hours dressing. Women used to spend so much time making their hair, makeup, and dress look perfect just to please their men who were just worried about money and raising their family. Nowadays, men are spending as much time on their appearance as women are. Are men really becoming that concerned about their health and figure? Are they really worried about their appearance as to go through with surgeries such as liposuction and hair transplant?
I think the articles Suck Out Your Gut by Sandy Naiman and Turning Boys into Girls by Michelle Cottle are very much parallel to each other in the sense both emphasize on the fact that men are getting concerned about their health and figure. Men, as much as women, have the right to be concerned about their figure and health. Just like women, men have to look in the mirror and they should like what they see. Men should be satisfied. In my opinions both of the articles have a very strong topic, but the arguments presented are fairly weak. Both authors show concerns that the men are starting to have about themselves.
Naiman's article shows the wrong way men are trying to improve themselves by using such techniques as liposuction, which can be very dangerous on the other hand, Cottle, in my opinion is being sexes and cant stand the fact that men can be figure cautious too. If one was to read both of the articles, its quite clear that both agree with the fact that men should be concerned about their health and figure, but to a limit. Cottle believes that these men magazines are making men Neurotic, insecure and Obsessive about their appearance as women, (EAA Pg. 428). Naiman uses the statistics that show the increase in the number of men using liposuction to satisfy themselves; Yet in 1997, Canadian and American members in the American Society of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons performed list! ction on 20, 192 men, compared to 6, 138 men in 1992 (Everythings an Argument, Pg. 425). Cottle shows the growing concern in male by the increase of Mens Health magazine, Since 1990, Mens Health has seen its paid circulation rise from 250, 000 to more than 1. 5 million (Pg. 431).
Naiman and Cottle both show the concern that men are getting to concerned about their figure, Naiman is more concerned about the medical treatment men are using to achieve self-satisfaction and Cottle, with lots of enthusiasm, gives the pros of men taking action towards a better figure. Naiman presents the argument that men who have become self-conscience are using medical treatment to satisfy themselves, which the author believes is not the right approach mainly because of the dangers the procedures hold. Cottle presents the argument of how women should accept the fact that men are building a competition between one another, men know that women go for the 6 -pack, the hot model-like figure, so they have become concerned. Naiman couldve presented the argument better by presenting other better ways that men can use, other than liposuction, to work on their figures. Naiman could have given the reader alternatives to medical procedures. As much as the article tried to show the cons of medical treatments, Naiman gives the example of a successful, but costly, liposuction procedure.
I dont regret one penny (of the $ 4, 700 plus GST) it cost. But I didnt realize what an invasive and serious procedure it is. Still, I heartily recommend it Brady (EAA, pg. 426). By presenting a successful liposuction experience, Naiman contradicts her own argument on how she is against the whole procedure. Cottle, throughout the entire article, from beginning to end enforces the idea how men should not get so concerned and how figure and fashion is womens thing. Cottle in my opinion is being very unreasonable and very unrealistic.
I think times have change and one of the changes time has brought upon us is this and! everyone should accept it. If magazines like Elle and Glamour are okay, than no one should have problems with the magazines for men. Lets not be hypocrites. In conclusion, Cottle and Naiman both pretty much are against the whole idea of men being so concerned with themselves, their appearance. I personally think that there is nothing wrong with it.
It is true that women have been the ones who held fashion and figure related concerns, but with time comes changes and everyone should accept it. We are living in the 21 st century, so we should be able to handle these changes especially when there is nothing wrong with it and honestly speaking, which women would want to wake up next to a man with a flabby belly and double chin? I am sure no one does. End of argument!
Free research essays on topics related to: liposuction, medical treatment, mirror, gut, sandy
Research essay sample on Turning Boys Into Girls Boys Into Girls Men
