NOTE: Free essay sample provided on this page should be used for references or sample purposes only. The sample essay is available to anyone, so any direct quoting without mentioning the source will be considered plagiarism by schools, colleges and universities that use plagiarism detection software. To get a completely brand-new, plagiarism-free essay, please use our essay writing service.
One click instant price quote
The nature vs. nurture debate, long contested by philosophers and scientists alike, is of special interest those charged with the responsibility of raising kids in a complicated, ever-changing world. While todays mothers and fathers must navigate the same child-rearing seas as their own parents did, they must also contend with the wide range of conflicting theory and advice recently generated by this volatile issue. Thankfully, in the face of a bewildering array of often-contradictory parental maps, a few solid guideposts stand out above the fray. The young science of ethno pediatrics is focused on collecting those discordant maps and exploring the differences and similarities between parenting styles of different cultures.
Anthropologist Meredith F. Small documents this work in Our Babies, Ourselves, a fascinating, pleasurable book that raises many questions: Is there a correct method of parenting? Are some methods more appropriate than others for a given environment? Who gets to ride in front? Small raises the possibility that the traditional (actually quite recently developed) American style may not be the best for our children, and shows that some of the behaviors we shy away from sleeping with infants and breastfeeding on demand, for example are much-used in other cultures, and our approach may reflect our own needs rather than whats good for the children.
Broadening the focus a bit, we find that we can learn much about the nature of nurture by studying other species. Science writer Susan Allport takes us out of the maternity ward with A Natural History of Parenting, a wide-ranging journey that often reflects on her own experience as a mother. Such a combination of the personal and the scientific makes for compelling reading, as in the passages detailing her work helping to birth lambs her frustration and ecstasy, as well as her scientific interest, become our own. Short on practical advice for us humans, Allport has nonetheless written a comforting book. (At least we dont eat our young! ) Taking the fashionable midpoint stance on the nature-nurture spectrum, neurologist Ann B. Barnet and her husband Richard give us a report on the latest scientific beliefs about the early development of children. The Youngest Minds is a surprisingly readable mixture of science review, advice manual, and consciousness- raising book, which should be at the top of every expectant parents reading list.
Whats going on in an infants brain? How does language develop? What can we do to foster emotional attachment? The Barnet's answer these questions and many more, being careful to remind us that neither neuroscience, developmental psychology, nor cultural anthropology tells us that there is only one right way to raise a child. But no matter what we may try to do while bringing up baby, he or she somehow still has to fit into our genes right?
Absolutely, says geneticist Dean Hamer in Living with Our Genes. He is careful not to say that our personalities are completely determined by our DNA, but he does offer impressive evidence that many traits such as depression, aggression, and sex drive have genetic origins. Does this mean parents should just give up and let nature do its work? Of course not.
Hamer writes about the difference between temperament (what were born with) and character (our flexibility and control over our nature), adding that many undesirable qualities of temperament may be controlled by building character. Hamer asks for a greater awareness of genetic issues in problem behavior and more sensible political approaches to genetic research; given them, he hopes to bring us all greater insight into our inescapable inheritance. It could be, though, that weve been going about this all wrong. Why did we choose to oppose nature and nurture as though they were the only influences on a childs development?
In The Nurture Assumption, Judith Rich Harris turns the field upside down by asking the question Why do we call environmental influences nurture? The word implies parental influence, but the scientific literature makes clear that our personalities are more a result of genetics and our peer relationships than any social connection we might have had with our parents. Harris is quick to tell us that this does not mean that parents are off the hook. As the final controllers of their childrens environments, they must make many important decisions, including where to raise them and how to manage their activities to best reach their potential. Love them, guide them, watch them grow. Maybe it is that simple.
Free research essays on topics related to: temperament, hamer, parenting, advice, nurture
Research essay sample on Nature Nurture Parents
