Customer center

We are a boutique essay service, not a mass production custom writing factory. Let us create a perfect paper for you today!

Example research essay topic: Quot A Quot Praying Mantis - 2,131 words

NOTE: Free essay sample provided on this page should be used for references or sample purposes only. The sample essay is available to anyone, so any direct quoting without mentioning the source will be considered plagiarism by schools, colleges and universities that use plagiarism detection software. To get a completely brand-new, plagiarism-free essay, please use our essay writing service.
One click instant price quote

Perhaps the most graphic example of formalism in dialogue with modern materialism is Zukofsky's sestina " Mantis, " which not only addresses the alienation of life under modern capitalism but does so by debating the " implications of a too regular form. " What is most interesting about Zukofsky's response to social crisis is that it is often conducted in formal terms that seem at odds with the material under consideration. This disparity has prompted Eric Mottram to speak of " A" - 9 s canzone structure as a kind of " dandyism" whose " strained versifying operates a trite statement of art taking its place as labour in 1938 - 40 " (98). Mottram's essay is one the best accounts of the difficulties of forging a materialist poetics, but it fails to historicism the oppositional meaning of Zukofsky's formalism with respect to competing theories of committed art during this period. Zukofsky used formalism not to aesthetic ize social tensions but to return a degree of use-value to an increasingly instrumental ized poetry. Rather than solve the problem as Open did giving up poetry altogether Zukofsky sought to provide an immanent critique within the terms of modernism itself. One way of understanding Zukofsky's formalism is to see it as a response to the larger issue of social reification.

In Luk? css canonical description, reification refers to the transformation of labor power into a commodity, the objectification of " sensuous human activity" into a " second nature. " Building upon Marx's notion of commodity fetishism in Capital, Luk? cs describes the process by which relations between individuals " take on the character of a thing and thus [acquire] a phantom objectivity" (83). As Marx dramatizes (in a passage quoted in " A" - 9), commodities seem to speak to each other, saying " our use-value may interest men, but it does not belong to us as objects. What does belong to us as objects, however is our value. Our own intercourse as commodities proves it.

We relate to each other merely as exchange-values" (176 - 77). As both Marx and Luk? cs argue, when commodities acquire independent agency, the workers role in creating them is occluded, leading to a sense of passivity and helplessness in the face of an autonomous, self-regulating market" auto telic" in every sense. Luk? cs is less interested in the specific economic factors contributing to reification than he is in the epistemological forces that maintain it. He describes the bourgeois philosophical tradition inherited from Kant as constructing a reflective consciousness that, while claiming power over its material surroundings, is unable to assess its own historical circumstance.

The bourgeoisie, since it is implicated in this contemplative attitude, cannot rupture it; but the proletariat potentially can understand its own historical moment and its alienation. What the proletariat " owns" is not labor power but a certain vantage by which the congealed version of that power in commodities can be seen for what it is. It is this vantage that preoccupies Zukofsky in his early poems and that becomes the focus of " Mantis. " " Mantis" concerns the perspective from which material conditions become detached from an observer. Rather than being about commodities or labor per se, the poem uses its own status as an aesthetic object as a lens for viewing social alienation.

And since the observer in this poem is also a poet, the work explores the degree to which " looking" and " writing" are implicated in a single mode of production. It is not that social reality is reproduced through the poem but that, through describing the inability of poetry to remove barriers between individuals, the poem generates a second vantage " produced" in the interstices between formal accomplishment (the poem as made thing) and social inadequacies (the absence of a unified proletarian consciousness). The poem consists of two parts sestina and an interpretation each of which augments and redefines the other. The sestina invokes the poets sudden encounter with a praying mantis in a subway station; the interpretation accounts for the sestina itself, situating the encounter with the mantis within a larger meditation on writing. It may seem odd that Zukofsky chooses such a complex literary vehicle to deal with " the growing oppression of the poor, " but the poems recycling of terminal words according to a numerical formula provides a felicitous frame for rendering " The actual twisting / Of many and diverse thoughts" invoked by the mantis. The sestina's invention is associated with Arnaut Daniel, who invented the form, but most important for Zukofsky is its use by Pound who, in The Spirit of Romance, described it as " a thin sheet of flame folding and infolding upon itself" (27).

Pound wrote several sestina's in his early career and regarded the form as a paragon of virtuosic difficulty, a touchstone for poetic apprenticeship. Zukofsky, no longer an apprentice, uses it to address Pound at a moment (1934) when the older poets increasing interest in Mussolini and Social Credit threatens their relationship. By subjecting the sestina to " ungainly" issues of poverty and urban alienation, Zukofsky confronts the dangers of poetic mastery divorced from the cultural and social institutions such mastery serves. Virtuosic control, as an end in itself, quickly becomes Stuffing like upholstery For parlor polish, And our time takes count against them For their blindness and their (unintended? ) cruel smugness. (All 76 - 77 [emphasis added]) Although Pound is not the antecedent here, a certain Victorian " smugness" associated with Pounds early personae is.

Although the title of the poem focuses on the mantis, clearly the subject is less the insect than the speakers ambivalent response to it: Mantis! praying mantis! since your wings leaves And your terrified eyes, pins, bright, black and poor Beg" look, take it up" (thoughts torsion)! " save it! " I who cant bear to look, cannot touch, You You cant no one sees you steadying lost In the cars drafts on the lit subway stone. (All 73) The shifting dennis of these lines dramatizes the speakers ambivalence, both to the mantis and to the poor. The ambiguity of " it" in the third line suggests that he addresses himself as much as the mantis. For Zukofsky is asking whether or how to " take up" the event, how to give it form and stabilize " thoughts torsion, " much as the insect strives to steady itself in the drafty subway. The confusion of first and second persons (" I who cant bear to look, cannot touch, You / You cant no one sees you" ) points to the speakers conflict about addressing those who challenge his autonomy.

Dennis fails to differentiate the subject from the eyes around him, and by the end of the stanza the question of whose eyes are seeing whom is thoroughly vexed, although understandable for a poet who consistently pronounced Is as " eyes. " The only witness to the poets discomfiture is the newsboy, but he is, in Luk? css terms, wrapped in the endless circulation of commodities, an extension of the reified history represented in his papers: Even the newsboy who now sees knows it No use, papers make money, makes stone, stone, Banks, " it is harmless, " he says moving on You? (All 73) In the interpretation, the market logic introduced here is shown to be circular. Rags make paper, paper makes money, money makes banks, banks make loans, loans make poverty, poverty makes rags. 79) It is precisely this vicious circularity to which Zukofsky's poetic form refers, even as it offers its own alternative semiotic economy for six recycled words. Likewise, the problems of dennis and perspective illustrate the difficulties of looking at another outside of market relationships. The mantis, by breaking through the speakers contemplative gaze, reminds him of cultural traditions that he has forgotten but nonetheless summons to explain the insects mythic meaning: Dont light on my chest, mantis! do youre lost, Let the poor laugh at my fright, then see it: My shame and theirs, you whom old Europe's poor Call spectre, strawberry, by turns; a stone You point they sanyo lead lost children (73 - 74) The speakers attraction to and repulsion from the mantis replicate his response to the poor, and by acknowledging " shame" he transforms self-closed river into vulnerability and even empathy.

By referring to " old Europe's poor, " Zukofsky acknowledges his own ethnic origins, sustained by the affirmative nature of shared narratives. Just as the mantis is able to " lead lost children" in an old story, so it saves one modern subject from isolation. At the end of the sestina, the poet realizes that, until he identifies his alienation with those around him, he cannot translate his subway experience for future generations. He urges the mantis to " Fly on the poor, " as it has alighted on him, " arise like leaves / The armies of the poor, strength; stone on stone / And build the new world in your eyes, Save it! " The paraphrase of the socialist motto (" Build the new world in the shell of the old" ) is varied here to include the acts of looking and identifying that have dominated the poem so far. But the final tercet presents a too-tidy conclusion to a poem that has opened up more problems than it has solved. If " Mantis" ended here, with the ringing injunction to " build the new world in your eyes, " we would have been left with the very aesthetic ized politics deplored by Mottram.

It is for " Mantis, an Interpretation" to return to the poem and dismantle the totalizing gesture implied by the form and manifested in its utopian apostrophe. Zukofsky's mandate to append an interpretation is granted by Dante, whose Vita Nuova offers an earlier example of poetry plus commentary (albeit in prose). And as with Dante, Zukofsky wishes to render a transformative experience by interpreting the condition surrounding words brought to bear on it: Mantis! Praying mantis! since your wings leaves Incipit Vita Nova le parole allen la loro sententia the words at least their substance at first were " The mantis opened its body It had been lost in the subway It steadied against the drafts It looked up Begging eyes It flew at my chest" The ungainliness of the creature needs stating. (All 74 - 75) Zukofsky includes a first-draft opening to the poem (" The mantis opened its body" ) to indicate his difficulty in finding words for an awkward moment. However " ungainly" these first twenty-seven words, they become the " pulses witness" to the event, just as Dantes " new life" begins with Beatrice's look.

Zukofsky's equivalent look combines the " Begging eyes" of the mantis with those of the poor. Zukofsky refuses to treat the mantis as a symbol, but he realizes that it " can start / History" by calling up disparate areas of knowledge and subjecting them to experience. Like Melville's whale, the mantis can become a curriculum: line 1 entomology line 9 biology lines 10 and 11 - the even rhythm of riding under- ground, and the sudden jolt are also of these nerves, glandular facilities, brains charges (All 78 - 79) This catalog, like the whimsical index at the end of " A" or the footnotes to " Poem Beginning The, " presumes to account for topics invoked by the mantis, but the more Zukofsky includes, the less he verifies. For the listing of facts alone cannot account for the " original shock" provoked by the insect. When facts remain ends in themselves, they signal their distance from any actual exchange.

What " Mantis" offers as a corrective is to provide " a use function of the material: / The original emotion remaining, / like the collective, / Unprompted" (79). For it is this " invoked collective" of disarranged and recombined facts that reestablishes contact, not to stop history with a verbal icon but to keep it alive and tangible in the present. " Mantis" and its interpretation are one poem seeing modern history through two pairs of eyes. We could speak of the sestina as embodying the modernist attempt to secure sight through the imposition of formal constraints, the humanist achievement of mastery over the quotidian, the mantis turned into a symbol of the poor. But in the interpretation we discern a postmodern (and we might say post-Marxist) attempt to deify the discourse of mastery in favor of internal critique. Neither poem exists without the other, just as the eyes of the mantis trade places with the eyes of its beholder.

From Ghostlier Demarcations: Modern Poetry and the Material Word. Copyright? 1997 by the Regents of the University of California.


Free research essays on topics related to: one sees, labor power, praying mantis, poor quot, quot a quot

Research essay sample on Quot A Quot Praying Mantis

Writing service prices per page

  • $18.85 - in 14 days
  • $19.95 - in 3 days
  • $23.95 - within 48 hours
  • $26.95 - within 24 hours
  • $29.95 - within 12 hours
  • $34.95 - within 6 hours
  • $39.95 - within 3 hours
  • Calculate total price

Our guarantee

  • 100% money back guarantee
  • plagiarism-free authentic works
  • completely confidential service
  • timely revisions until completely satisfied
  • 24/7 customer support
  • payments protected by PayPal

Secure payment

With EssayChief you get

  • Strict plagiarism detection regulations
  • 300+ words per page
  • Times New Roman font 12 pts, double-spaced
  • FREE abstract, outline, bibliography
  • Money back guarantee for missed deadline
  • Round-the-clock customer support
  • Complete anonymity of all our clients
  • Custom essays
  • Writing service

EssayChief can handle your

  • essays, term papers
  • book and movie reports
  • Power Point presentations
  • annotated bibliographies
  • theses, dissertations
  • exam preparations
  • editing and proofreading of your texts
  • academic ghostwriting of any kind

Free essay samples

Browse essays by topic:

Stay with EssayChief! We offer 10% discount to all our return customers. Once you place your order you will receive an email with the password. You can use this password for unlimited period and you can share it with your friends!

Academic ghostwriting

About us

© 2002-2024 EssayChief.com