NOTE: Free essay sample provided on this page should be used for references or sample purposes only. The sample essay is available to anyone, so any direct quoting without mentioning the source will be considered plagiarism by schools, colleges and universities that use plagiarism detection software. To get a completely brand-new, plagiarism-free essay, please use our essay writing service.
One click instant price quote
Compare two stories having similar themes. Explain what you believe the theme to be and how it can be compared in the two different plots. Alice Walkers Everyday Use and D. H. Lawrence's The Horse Dealers Daughter are the two stories with different plots. In the first one, the narrator is a black woman who is a single mother and has two daughters.
One of her daughters, Maggie, is only a shadow of her beautiful and educated sister. The second story is about a young woman, Mabel, who is constantly looked down by her brothers and whose life does not have any significance. Even though the stories seem to be different at the first sight, they have similar themes and ideas. Both concentrate on the lives of young women, who are deeply unhappy and deprived of anything good. Maggie and Mabel are poor women, who live in rural areas. In Everyday Use the financial situation of the character has, apparently, never been good.
It is a black family living in the South, growing pigs and cows. In the second story, however, the family portrayed was once rich. The father, who was a horse dealer, had a good business, but then everything went wrong and he left his children in heavy debt. Financial burdens have made characters of both stories pessimistic and their lives do not seem to have any particular goal. The environment portrayed in each of the essays is very depressing, even ugly. In both stories the main characters are young women, who are deprived of happiness by the bad fortune and other people.
Both girls have had some horrifying events happening to them when they were little, making great prints on their lives and personalities. For Maggie, it was a fire, in which she was trapped and left disabled. This fire made her very shy, even ashamed, of herself and her burn scars down her legs and arms. She does not feel herself to be in her plate when her sister Dee is around. This woman is getting married soon, but is still hiding behind her mothers back when Dee comes.
Maggie is a very sad character, because she does not have any friends, she is spending most of her time in the company of her old mother and is getting married to John Thomas who is portrayed as someone who has mossy teeth in the earnest face. The main character of The Horse Dealers Daughter, Mabel, is also an unhappy person. In the beginning of the story, she is portrayed as a walking zombie, who does not have any dear person in the entire world. She is disrespected by her brothers, called bulldog and constantly pressured to move out and go live with her sister. There were two events that made Mabel what she is now: the first one was the death of her mother when she was only 14. Mother was everything for the girl and Mabel misses her ever since she died.
The second event, which put the final drop to completely destroying Mabel's happiness, was the second marriage of her father. Mabel also does not have any friends, does not care for anything or anybody, including herself. As a result of such a desperate life, the woman decides to kill herself. Ironically, this terrible decision becomes her luckiest one and she, finally, finds her love. So different at the first glimpse, Everyday Use and The Horse Dealers Daughter have very similar, almost identical themes. Both stories narrate about lives of poor rural girls who are going with the stream of ugly routine and misery.
It seems that these essays are devoted to the figures of unhappy young women, who suffer horrible lives because of something that has happened to them in the past. Even though the mood and language of these narratives is very sad and depressive, each one ends with a symbolic optimism and a hope for the better future. There could be no better ending for the overwhelmed with sympathy readers, who believe that both women deserve more than they have now.
Free research essays on topics related to: horse dealers daughter, young women, second story, mabel, first one
Research essay sample on Horse Dealers Daughter Young Women
