NOTE: Free essay sample provided on this page should be used for references or sample purposes only. The sample essay is available to anyone, so any direct quoting without mentioning the source will be considered plagiarism by schools, colleges and universities that use plagiarism detection software. To get a completely brand-new, plagiarism-free essay, please use our essay writing service.
One click instant price quote
"Some traits or dispositions are inherited, but the continuity of behavior, including antisocial activity, is maintained by social contexts and other aspects of the Criminal insanity is a topic which sparks much heated debate. What causes insanity? Is insanity a physical or psychological problem? Is insanity actually a disease, or just a figment of a persons imagination? Groliers Encyclopedia describes insanity as "a mental defect or disorder sufficient to prevent a person from knowing the difference between right and wrong conduct or from understanding the nature of his or her actions. " This definition is one which would seem to be a good representation of what insanity truly is. Insanity applies to criminals in an interesting way.
If a criminal does not know the difference between right and wrong then can they be held accountable for the crimes they commit? If they don't understand that what they are doing is a crime then should they be punished as if they were criminals or treated as patients with a disease? This problem is one that has plagued courts, lawyers, juries and defendants for a long time and does not appear to be any closer to a solution. A common belief as to why people first become criminally insane is because of the way they were treated as children.
Many examples to support this theory can be found throughout history. One example is the infamous Charles Manson. Charles Manson's' home life was anything but normal; he was, in fact, the son of a "teenage, bisexual, alcoholic prostitute, and was once traded for a pitcher of beer" ("Charles... "). Another example is Henry Lee Lucas, a famous serial killer, who "as a child, lost an eye after a severe beating from his mother" ("Serial... "). Finally, Pedro Alonso Lopez, believed to be the key player in over 300 murders was "kicked out of his house when only 8 years old" ("Serial... "). These cases, as well as many others, seem to indicate a correlation between abuse as a child and violent tenancies as an adult.
A renowned psychologist, Server Frazier, has concluded that many "killers have been subjected to brutalizing treatment that generated overwhelming hostile and ultimately murderous emotions in them. Many had bean beaten repeatedly or sexually abused as children" (Methvin 35). Another common link has been found that proves that people who act violently as children will most likely grow up to do the same. For instance, Jeffrey Dahmer as a child "liked to torture and kill animals. As an adult he did the same to Although criminal insanity is often thought to be a purely psychological disorder much proof has appeared over the years to have sparked a theory that criminal insanity is not in fact psychological, but instead a physical disorder. Dr.
Adrian Raine, of the University of South California, is one believer of this theory. In his studies and tests he has found "that in psychopathic murderers there was less activity in the prefrontal cortex of the brain" ("Natural Born... " 10). Could this lack of activity in an area of the brain that is known to control certain emotions in people be the cause of criminal insanity? It is possible, but that is most likely not the only cause. Dr. Raine says that he believes that violent and psychopathic behavior is caused by environmental factors in additional to biological ones ("Natural Born... " 10).
Many other psychiatrists and doctors feel the same way as Dr. Raine does. One psychiatrist, Dr. George B. Palermo uses CAT scans to "electronically scan the brain" ("Doctor is Allowed... " 11) of criminals to determine if they where criminally insane at the time of the murders they committed.
Dr. Palermo also suggested the use of chromosome analysis for the same purpose. "Some specialists say chromosomes, which carry hereditary characteristics, are similar among the criminally insane and could indicate a persons tendency to criminal behavior", he says ("Doctor... " 11). These scientists, doctors, and psychiatrists feel that there is a deeper, biological reason for criminal insanity. Many scientists believe that there are ways to predict who will eventually become criminally insane or commit horrendous crimes. Bruce Bower, author of "Delinquent Development", says that "youngsters who spent most of their childhoods with behavioral and social problems and entered puberty earlier than their peers seemed most likely to turn to violent crime. " As Ronald Holmes says, "Mental health professionals and probation / parole officers may be in a position to recognize potentially dangerous people who are physically - and more importantly - psychologically poised for fatal violence on a large scale" (10). By saying this Holmes points out how important it is for these professionals to always be on the lookout for a person with the potential to become criminally insane.
Holmes also points out how these people might indeed make it possible to prevent someone from a psychological breakdown that will eventually lead to them becoming insane and possibly criminally insane. Although psychologists must always be alert for signs of mental illness in a person the justice system must watch for the possibility of someone being criminally insane as well. For example, "Charles Manson was an ex-convict and had spent more than half his life in prison before the age of 35 " ("Charles... "). Why the court system didn't identify the potential in Manson to become criminally insane is unexplainable.
Psychiatrist Helen L. Morrison, and expert on criminal psychology has said about the criminally insane, "These are basically cookie-cutter people, so much alike psychologically I could close my eyes and be talking to any one of them. They are phenomenally alike in the way their psychology is set, the way they function, and how they " re misdiagnosed" (Methvin, 35). If this is true, and these criminally insane are so alike then one would think that there should be some kind of "cookie-cutter" way to diagnose if a person will become criminally insane or not. For some reason this is not the case.
Even though these personalities are so similar they are different enough to evade any system of detection that has been devised as of yet. Dr. Morrison says that a criminally insane persons "psychological development... stops at about six months of age. As an infant, [he] does not develop the ability to differentiate himself from others; he cannot distinguish a human being from, say, a chair or any other inanimate object" (Methvin 35).
Is this what the criminally insane see the world as? A conglomeration of lifeless objects that have no true importance and therefore it does not matter whether they live or die? Dr. Morrison says about insane criminals, "Murder to him is no more than child's play, like taking apart a clock to see what makes it tick" (Methvin, 35). It would appear that this is indeed the way they see other human beings. Although in theory all of these ideas to identify people who have the potential to become criminally insane in later life seems wonderful in practice it rarely ever works.
This is proved by Ed Kemper, a famous serial killer. "Once he visited his court appointed psychic...
Free research essays on topics related to: natural born, difference between right and wrong, charles manson, serial killer, insane
Research essay sample on Difference Between Right And Wrong Serial Killer
