NOTE: Free essay sample provided on this page should be used for references or sample purposes only. The sample essay is available to anyone, so any direct quoting without mentioning the source will be considered plagiarism by schools, colleges and universities that use plagiarism detection software. To get a completely brand-new, plagiarism-free essay, please use our essay writing service.
One click instant price quote
In order to answer the question posed, I will examine what is meant by the term Utopian Socialism. With reference to this question I will conduct a brief biographical study of one of the great utopian socialist thinkers, Robert Owen. This will include an examination of the accomplishments of Robert Owen. The essay will then move on to examine the central criticisms of the utopian socialists as levelled by Karl Marx. The term Utopian Socialism as defined in the Dictionary of Politics highlights Utopianism as "An approach to social or political theory based upon the design of a perfect society." (Robertson, (1993) pg 479) Such thinkers as Owen and St Simon dreamt of "class unity rather than the abolition of classes." (Marx and Engels, (1848) pg 73) Marx was highly critical of the belief that there could ever be such a situation that would promote class unity. Marx went on to argue that "the utopians dreamt of class unity rather than the abolition of class.
The utopians are belated enlightenment idealists who think their blueprint could simply be imposed on the world." (Marx and Engels, (1848), pg 134). Robert Owen in order to test his political theory purchased a huge spinning mill at New Lanarkshire. His experiences and experiments would prove to make him famous and spawn his many ideas of socialist / communal living. After becoming owner of the mill Owen became aware of the awful conditions under which many of the workers lived.
The mere fact that Owen was the owner of the factory brought much scorn from the likes of Marx and Engels. Marx argued that "in the formation of their plans, they are conscious of caring chiefly for the interest of the working class, as being the most suffering class. Only from the point of view of being the most suffering class does the proletariat exist for them." (Marx and Engels (1848, pg 73) It us clear that Marx was to use the fact that Owen was a member of the bourgeoisie to deride Owen's utopian blueprint. Owen's political theory was instrumental in the instigation of improvements within the following areas: housing, reduction of working hours, child employment, education and raising living conditions. This led the utopian socialists to argue that is was possible to witness a peaceful and productive industrial community. Marx however argued that due to the dawning of a new industrial era "society as a whole is more and more splitting up into two great hostile camps, into two great classes directly facing each other, the bourgeoisie and the proletariat." (Marx and Engels, (1848), pg 33) Owen became convinced that the advancement of humankind could be furthered by the improvement of every individual's personal environment.
He reasoned that since "character was moulded by circumstances, then improved circumstances would lead to goodness" (Web page, A Web of English History, 11 / 04 / 02) This was a far cry from the revolutionary ideals of Marx and Engels who argued that the advancement of human kind would only be seen when the "workers of the world unite" (Marx and Engels, (1848) pg 72) One of the most crucial components of Owen's political theory is that of morality. This attitude manifests itself in several ways. In its philosophical outlook of the world Owen believed that one's surroundings at birth would determine how an individual would behave. In other words, "society creates the character of the individual and he is at its mercy.
Men do no wrong; they are impelled by their surroundings." (Sargent, (1971), pg 4) Marx would argue that man, far from being impelled by his surroundings "can and must liberate himself." (Marx and Engels (1848, pg 41) In terms of political change Owen and many of the utopian socialists argued that the working class would not take part in political agitation. "Owen was convinced that through representative government that was tolerant, prosperity and happiness would be achievable by all." (Pollard and Salt, 1971, pg 42) Marx and Engels were critical of Owen's belief that governments could be tolerant and representative. They argued that in order that, "classes with conflicting economic interest, shall not consume themselves and society in fruitless struggle, it became necessary to have a power seemingly standing above society that would moderate the conflict and keep it within the bounds of 'order'; and this power, arisen out of society but placing itself about it and alienating itself more and more from it, is the state." (Engels, (1884), pg 205 - 6) It is clear to follow Engels' view that far from a representative government instigating happiness and prosperity, as the government consisted of the bourgeoisie, it would be the bourgeoisie that prospered yet again at the expense of the proletariat. Another criticism by Marx of the utopian ideology was that he did not see the utopian ideology as being scientific. He believed that the utopians constructed ideas through thought, believing that if man could simply accept the utopian ideals then society's problems would be solved.
This approach which "consists of working out in one's head the Student ID No 11039772 Modern European Thought Why was Karl Marx so disparaging of the utopian socialists? answer to the world's problems" (Eddy, 1979, pg 88) was totally rejected by Marx. He saw socialism as a science that came about as a result of conflict from within existing forces in society. He argued that only through society progression would any solutions for the major social problems that existed be found. In their book, "The German Ideology", by Marx and Engles, they stated in direct contradiction to the utopian way of thinking that, "It is a matter not of setting out from what men say, imagine, conceive, nor from men as narrated, thought of, imagined, conceived, in order to arrive at men in the flesh; but of setting out from real, active men, and on the basis of their real life process demonstrating the development of the ideological reflexes and echoes of this life-process." (Marx and Engels (1848) pg 43) Here Marx and Engels are arguing that it is not sufficient to just believe in a theory or think of a theory. There has to be empirical evidence that will give a good indication of the way forward.
Marx as a journalist and a political agitator was committed to his belief that "the efforts to understand the social processes, which were afoot, and the political efforts to create such a society, required a rigorous scientific study of man and society. (Fletcher, (1971) pg 341) Marx was adamant in his belief that it was a scientific fact that socialism would be a conclusion to a track in history whereby slave society led to a feudal society, feudalism led to a capitalist society and capitalism would eventually lead to socialism. This idea was challenged by the utopians that argued that even if capitalism did lead to socialism then it would not necessarily be scientific. They argued that if capitalism did indeed co...
Free research essays on topics related to: utopian socialists, marx and engels, karl marx, representative government, political theory
Research essay sample on Marx And Engels Utopian Socialists
